Sunday, June 11, 2006

about thursday

thursday i went to the high school's spring choral concert. the experience felt rather surreal. after all, two short years ago, i was one of those well-dressed students singing my heart out for the audience. now, i'm watching. not participating. to add to this feeling of detachment, this was the first choir concert i've heard since i graduated. so i went from in choir, to two years on the opposite coast, to sitting and listening. all this was made even stranger by the fact that they sang one of the songs we sang my sophomore year - when david heard. it's a gorgeous piece - the kind that gives shivers and pulls off your skin. love it. but... the high school choir had between 24 and 26 members, and... there are 18 parts in a few sections. it's the only song i've ever seen with 18 parts. it's this wonderful, huge tone cluster that sounds awful unless done by human voices. of course, the pitches must be perfect for it to ring correctly. and i know that song. not only did i sing it four years ago, but i have a very good recording of it (BYU concert choir, i think) which i've listened to quite a bit since then. so now, when i hear david, i hear it done perfectly - the right pitches, great blend. although i do like lindy's directorial interpretation better... so when madrigals sang david on thursday, it was painful. the first two chords were off... so it started badly. most of the normal 8-part sections they did ok on. but they had issues with timing and pitch, and that sort of thing really bothers me. i'm afraid i'd rather have a choir not blend, but hit the correct pitches than the other way around. this year's choir blends well. i grant them that. my choir didn't - we had too many people with solo voices who just didn't blend. but i think we had more people capable of holding their own pitch, against pitches only a half step or one whole step away. (the tone cluster starts on the A at the bottom of bass clef... goes to the D above it, then the E right next to that, then F, G, A, Bb, C, D, E, F, G, A, Bb, C,
D, E, and ending on F in the first sopranoes.) in my choir, both first soprano notes (E and F) were hit. in this choir... the top note was missing every dang time. it drove me crazy. that note is more important than the E, especially since the cluster resolves to a chord with that F on top. grrr. i don't actually know how my choir sounded singing this piece, but i know this choir did
NOT do it justice. for a high school choir, it was impressive... but in all honesty, what high school choir - especially one from a public county high school of under 1000 students - can be expected to do justice to a piece of this caliber? it's by eric whitacre, whose stuff is crazy to begin with, and when david heard is possibly the most difficult piece i have EVER seen. and that's saying something - i've seen a lot. so anyway, i was disappointed by that song... but they did a good job on cloudburst (another whitacre piece, in spanish), probably partly cause they've been singing it so long. and the harmonies are easier. and o sifuni mungu sounded great. the soloes at the beginning were especially good (and no, i'm not saying this just because my brother was one of them). so basically, david was the only piece they biffed. and there's no way they could've done it convincely anyway. with 18 parts for over 8 long measures, if only one person is on a part, they must breath, so they can't get the continuity. but, one good thing, the sopranoes got their top high C very well. that was good.

then afterwards, it was the standard denny's run. i got roped into coming by a couple people from my year... it went ok. but there's nothing like watching and hearing a group of kids very loudly enjoying themselves to make you feel left out and lacking in any social life. yar. i miss seeing people every day. i need to call people more...

but things are ok now. i've got the first season of lost, which i'm going to watch. haven't seen any of it, but it sounds interesting. we'll see what i think. life goes on...

No comments: